All it
takes is one false allegation of abuse and you too could be living the
nightmare that is reality for many men in Ontario
By Tom
Thompson, Justice Reporter
"What is that God
awful banging, it’s 3am" thinks
John Smith as he rolls out of bed to
see who could be hammering on his door at such a ridiculous hour. A
multitude of worrisome thoughts flow
through his head such as, “Oh my God
something has happened to my child, has there been an accident”
As
he descends the stairs to answer the door he is stricken with terror at the
sight of two uniformed police officers visible through the window beside his
front door. "Oh no"
John thinks to himself, “it’s true, my worst
nightmare is happening. Something awful has happened to my child, the
police don’t come at this hour unless something tragic has happened”
He
reaches out to open the door and greets the officers, absolute terror etched
on his face. “Hello officer, what has happened to my child? Please
tell me nothing has happened to my child” John asked the first officer.
“Are you Mr. John Smith?” the first officer demands
of John. “Yes I am” John replies.
“Sir you are under arrest for assault
against your former spouse. You
are going to have to come down to the station with us"
says the officer.
“There must be some mistake officer, I have not assaulted my former spouse or
anyone else” John vehemently states to the officers. “I am sorry sir, we have
had a complaint from your wife that you assaulted her earlier this evening and
you are going to jail” respond the officers in unison.
“No No No” that’s not true, please I will lose my job if I go to jail” John
cries. “you should have thought of that before you beat your wife up Smith”
the officers respond with a barely-concealed
smirk.
“Turn around and place your hands behind your back please” John is told. “Can
I put my clothes on first please officer, I am in my underwear” John cries.
“Just do what you are told sir and
this will go a lot easier on you” “I
can’t believe this is happening to me” John thinks to himself as he is lead
half naked out of his home and into the marked patrol unit at the curb.
As
the patrol unit moves through his neighbourhood John can feel the eyes of his
neighbours and friends peering at him through their windows further adding to
his feelings of humiliation and confusion.
“Stand up and remove your underwear Mr. Smith” a voice barks at John causing
him to start. He
is weeps into his hands. He is
mortified and humiliated at the thought of standing naked in front of strangers.
John is led to an interrogation room by one officer and told of the charges
against him.” May I tell you my side of the story please” John begs the
officer. “Your ex wife said you hit her and that’s all we need to know Smith”
the officer replies.
“I
want to call a lawyer” John states to the officer. “a lawyer isn’t going to
help you Smith, domestic violence perpetrators go to jail with or without a
lawyer” the officer responds with a smug and condescending smile.
The officer stands aside and tells John to get into the holding cell, with a
vicious shove to the middle of his back John is propelled into the cell and
falls to the floor cutting his head and knocking out a tooth.
John is freezing, there is no blanket anywhere in sight and the cold metal bed
offers no warmth. John’s clothes and belongings have been confiscated from him
and the officers are not answering his calls for a blanket.
Slowly John opens his eyes, he is not sure how much time has passed, as he
takes in his surroundings a guttural cry erupts from John, “WHEN AM I GOING TO
WAKE UP FROM THIS NIGHTMARE” he screams.
Some readers may believe that the above story is mere
fiction but sadly it is not. Surely
the name John Smith is fictitious but the circumstances of Mr. Smith’s
story are all too real for many men who are the victims of false allegations
of abuse by a woman in Ontario. And they
number in the thousands.